This and That

Random bits of my life

Book Review: A Scuola di Puncetto Valsesiano

Posted by Avital Pinnick on March 24, 2011

A Sculoa di Puncetto Valsesiano

Carlo Rosetti, Paola Scarrone, and Angela Stefanutto, A Scuola di Puncetto Valsesiano (Società Operaia di Mutuo Soccorso, 2009). 112 pages. €30, available from (excellent service! No affiliation, just a satisfied customer.)

Sample page:

A Sculoa di Puncetto Valsesiano

Puncetto Valsesiano, an Italian needle lace, has captivated many with its elegant, austere designs and apparent simplicity. The only materials required are a needle and thread. The lace is created entirely with a simple overhand knot, made by looping the thread around the needle. Unfortunately, there is very little information about Puncetto in English, apart from the Anchor Manual of Needlework and Gentle Arts.

You are probably wondering whether this book be used by someone who doesn’t read Italian. The answer is “Yes,” as long as you are comfortable with schematic diagrams (like the charts in Burda crochet magazines) and enjoy solving puzzles. These diagrams are comprehensible without knowing Italian (I’m currently working on a short glossary to translate terms found in this book, which may make some things easier). Each small red square represents a single stitch, 2 rows. The blue square represents 2 stitches, 4 rows, and so on. When you skip a single stitch, the small vertical red line may look like a knot, but it is actually a loop; you are skipping one loop or two knots.

An important point to keep in mind is that the diagrams are a graphical shorthand for describing the Puncetto motifs. They are not exact depictions, in the way that filet crochet or cross-stitch charts are. Because successive rows of stitches are offset, like bricks in a wall, they cannot be shown on a grid. I recommend that you practice the simpler motifs, such as blocks, spiders, etc., before you tackle the more advanced design because if you do not have a good grasp of the structure of the basic motif, you will run into trouble (usually too many or not enough stitches when you finish a row).

This book provides a rich variety of motifs and edgings, far more than I’ve seen in any other source. There are “stars” (“stars” are actually the small square motifs that form the basis for strips and doilies), corners, edgings, scallops, picots, circular motifs, triangles, diagonally worked corners, and doily centers — even leaves, much like the leaves of bobbin lace. The basic knot is briefly described with photos. In theory, a beginner could use this book and develop a large repertoire of motifs. The only materials required are a needle and cotton thread, usually size 30, but sometimes size 80-100 is used, with correspondingly fine needles.

The sample page above contains a fairly typical lesson, with a motif on the left side and a gorgeous finished piece on the right. Before you get too excited, you should know that this is not a pattern book. For example, the wide edging with corner on the right page is not accompanied by an actual pattern. However, if the pattern is not too complicated, you should be able to duplicate it if you master the basic motifs. That’s the beauty of Puncetto — once you’ve mastered the basics, it’s fairly easy to copy patterns from photographs. The photos of Puncetto that appear on dark blue backgrounds (left page in the photo above) are the only ones accompanied by instructions.

I made one of the motifs, #12, “Ragni piccoli uniti,” and found the chart to be accurate. DMC Cebelia 30 with a size 26 tapestry needle worked very well.

I do have a few quibbles about this book. First, there are no page numbers. The numbers beside the titles refer to sections, usually dedicated to a type of motif. I often had trouble remembering where to find things in the book. It also means that the book cannot be indexed. There is a table of contents at the end of the book but the numbers refer to sections, not pages. If you need to refer to a motif, you will have to use say something like “Section #38, 52-stitch square.”

Sometimes the coloured squares appear to be out of sync with the grid. The reason for this is that the grid of grey lines is based on two stitches; a single, small square is two stitches wide and two stitches high. Patterns based on three stitches look strange when superimposed on the grey grid (for example, the two large squares of #20, Stelle con rosette piccole ed autin), but the stitch count seems to be accurate. Each square or stella has a label indicating the size of the base you need to work (for example, Punti 46).

The quality of the book is generally very high. The paper is heavy, the colour reproduction is good, the diagrams are clear, and the photos are beautifully styled, lit, and sharp enough to count the stitches. The weakest part of the book is the binding. I handled my book fairly gently but the cover is starting to fall off. It’s not a deal-breaker because the signatures are sewn and the cover can be glued later if necessary, but one expects a soft-cover book of this price to keep its cover longer than a week. It’s probably best to photocopy a working copy of a pattern rather than leaving the book open. Despite these shortcomings, I highly recommend this book.

Broken Binding

7 Responses to “Book Review: A Scuola di Puncetto Valsesiano”

  1. Hi Avital

    I have been following you on your wonderful journey of discovery with Puncetto Valsesiano – I discovered you on your journey as I started to research this particular type of needlelace in order to finish a group of accessories for a class project (which comes to fruition this weekend 15-17 April).

    I too purchased this book and, like you, had wonderful service from Italian Needlecrafts.

    I’m glad to read the comments you make about this book – as you have obviously had a similar experience to me with the binding falling apart, and the frustration at the lack of page numbers. Having said all that – I am blown away with the beauty of the photographs and have really enjoyed the puzzle-solving required to make sense of the diagrams.

    Your glossary of Italian words helps no end – and one day I plan to have enough Italian myself to go and learn this lace-making art from the school itself.

    I would like to extend my sincere thanks for all your interpretation and tuition on this particular needlelace … my attempts so far are quite basic, but I feel I will be able to impart a little bit of history and a great deal of enthusiasm for this lace to my students.

    with kindest regards

  2. […] book builds on the basic tutorials and motifs provided in A Scuola di Puncetto Valsesiano although, interestingly, it was published three years before Scuola. Its format and diagrams are […]

  3. carmen said

    Hola, necesito comprar este libro u otro similar en Chile.
    ¿saben donde?

    • Avital Pinnick said

      I’m sorry, but now it’s very difficult to find this book anywhere. The “Italian Needlework” site used to sell it but now it’s closed. You might be able to find a copy on eBay. Or try writing directly to the publisher. Good luck!

  4. Aruna said

    Hi where can I buy this book. I belong to the embroidery guild in Sydney and very interested in needle lace

    • Avital Pinnick said

      Unfortunately, the Puncetto Valsesiano books were in print for a very short time and are unlikely to be reprinted. I think your best bet would be to create saved searches (with notifications) on eBay and Sometimes a lacemaker or needleworker passes and the descendants dump all the books on one of those sites to sell them. Good luck!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: